Child Custody

Are Breathalyzer Applications Useful in Custody Cases

Chris Wise
December 18, 2023
3 min read

When it comes to custody cases involving alcohol abuse or a history of drinking, the well-being and safety of the children are of utmost importance. The use of breathalyzer applications can potentially serve as a tool to monitor and ensure the sobriety of the party with the drinking history. However, it is essential to carefully evaluate the benefits and limitations of such applications before deciding to incorporate them into your case.

What are the limitations of utilizing a Breathalyzer Application?

Breathalyzer applications, while potentially useful in certain situations, do have limitations that should be considered. One significant limitation is that these applications can only provide evidence of sobriety at the time of testing. They cannot account for alcohol consumption that may have occurred outside of the testing period. This means that a person could potentially consume alcohol immediately after the test and still be under the influence when caring for the children.

Accuracy and Reliability

Another limitation is the accuracy and reliability of portable breathalyzer devices or smartphone apps. The effectiveness of these devices can vary, and their results may not always be completely accurate. Factors such as calibration, user error, or environmental conditions can impact the reliability of the readings. This can lead to challenges in court regarding the validity and admissibility of the breathalyzer results as evidence.

It is also important to consider the potential for false positives or false negatives with breathalyzer applications. False positives can occur if the device detects alcohol in the breath due to factors other than actual alcohol consumption, such as certain medications or mouthwash. False negatives, on the other hand, can occur if the device fails to detect alcohol even when the person has consumed it. These possibilities can raise questions about the reliability and validity of the breathalyzer results.

Privacy Intrusions

Additionally, the use of breathalyzer applications may raise privacy concerns. Requiring a party to regularly submit breath samples can be seen as intrusive and may infringe upon their privacy rights. This can be particularly relevant in custody cases where the court must balance the need for ensuring the safety of the children with the rights and dignity of the parties involved.

Admissibility in Court

Furthermore, the admissibility of breathalyzer results as evidence in court can be subject to challenge. The opposing party may question the accuracy, reliability, or relevance of the breathalyzer readings. They may argue that the results should not be considered as conclusive evidence of sobriety or lack thereof. This can lead to additional legal complexities and potential disputes during the custody case.

It is important to consult with your attorney to understand the specific laws and regulations regarding the admissibility and use of breathalyzer applications in custody cases in your jurisdiction. Your attorney can provide guidance on the potential benefits and drawbacks of incorporating such evidence and help you navigate the legal process effectively.

What are the benefits of utilizing a breathalyzer application?

Breathalyzer applications, such as portable devices or smartphone apps, offer several benefits in custody cases where one party has a history of drinking. These applications provide objective evidence of sobriety or alcohol consumption by measuring the blood alcohol concentration (BAC) through breath samples. By requiring the party with the drinking history to regularly submit breath samples, breathalyzer applications can establish a pattern of sobriety and provide reassurance regarding their ability to responsibly care for the children.

Demonstrates a Commitment to Sobriety

In custody cases, the primary concern is the best interests of the children. The court takes into account various factors, including the history of alcohol abuse, the ability to provide a safe and stable environment, and the willingness to prioritize the children's well-being. By incorporating breathalyzer applications, you can demonstrate a commitment to sobriety and responsible parenting, potentially influencing the court's decision in your favor.

Objective Evidence of Sobriety

The use of breathalyzer applications can provide objective evidence of sobriety, which can be crucial in cases where alcohol abuse has been a concern. It offers a tangible way to monitor and document the party's commitment to sobriety and responsible behavior. By regularly submitting breath samples, the party can establish a pattern of sobriety over time, which can help alleviate concerns about their ability to care for the children safely.

Builds Trust with the Court

Furthermore, breathalyzer applications can help build trust and confidence in the party's ability to prioritize the children's well-being. By voluntarily incorporating this technology, it demonstrates a proactive approach to addressing any concerns about alcohol consumption. It shows a willingness to take responsibility and be accountable for one's actions, which can be viewed favorably by the court.

Incorporating breathalyzer applications can also provide peace of mind for both parties involved. It offers a clear and objective measure of sobriety, reducing potential disputes or disagreements about alcohol consumption. This can help create a more stable and harmonious co-parenting environment, which is beneficial for the children's emotional well-being.

In conclusion, the use of breathalyzer applications in custody cases involving a party with a history of drinking can be worth considering. They can provide objective evidence of sobriety and demonstrate a commitment to responsible parenting. However, it is important to carefully evaluate the benefits and limitations of such applications and consult with your attorney to ensure their proper use within the legal framework of your jurisdiction.

Louisville    Indianapolis    Cincinnati    Nashville

We're here to guide you

Call to Action